Explore all head-to-head comparisons →

Head to head

The 5%ers vs Blue Guardian

A side-by-side look at The 5%ers and Blue Guardian: the evaluation fees recorded for each firm, which programs and platforms they offer, and how traders rate them. Every figure is sourced and dated below.

DetailThe 5%ersBlue Guardian
Cheapest standard challenge$300
$100K 3-Step · source, 2026-10-19
$239
$100K 2-Step · source, 2026-10-19
Challenge types1-Step, 2-Step, 3-Step1-Step, 2-Step, 3-Step, Instant
Trader rating4.7 / 54.2 / 5
Reviews1,338233
Max allocation$250K$400K
PlatformsMT5TradingViewcTraderMT5Match TraderTradeLocker
MarketsFXMetalsIndicesEnergyCryptoFXIndicesCryptoOther Commodities
Founded20162021
HeadquartersUnited KingdomUnited Arab Emirates

Key differences

  • Blue Guardian's cheapest standard $100K evaluation is $61 cheaper ($239 vs $300). Compare the rules attached to each price, not just the price.
  • The 5%ers has the higher published trader rating (4.7 vs 4.2), from 1,338 reviews.
  • Blue Guardian lists Instant program that The 5%ers does not in our dataset.
  • Both offer MT5. Only The 5%ers lists TradingView and cTrader. Only Blue Guardian lists Match Trader and TradeLocker.
  • Blue Guardian reports the higher maximum allocation ($400K), usually reached through scaling or multiple accounts.
  • The 5%ers has the longer track record, founded in 2016 (5 years earlier).
  • Markets listed only by The 5%ers: Metals and Energy.
  • Markets listed only by Blue Guardian: Other Commodities.
Consider The 5%ers if
  • published trader sentiment is a priority for you
  • you prefer a firm with a larger body of trader reviews
  • a longer operating history matters to you
  • you trade on TradingView and cTrader

The 5%ers profile →

Consider Blue Guardian if
  • you want the lower entry fee at the same account size
  • you want a Instant program
  • you trade on Match Trader and TradeLocker
  • you plan to scale towards a larger total allocation

Blue Guardian profile →

What this comparison does not cover

Drawdown type, daily loss limits, consistency rules and payout terms differ by program and change often, so we do not summarise them here. Before you buy, read each firm's current rules for the exact program and size you want, and check them against our drawdown guide and payouts guide.

Frequently asked questions

Which is cheaper, The 5%ers or Blue Guardian?

At the time we checked, The 5%ers's cheapest standard $100K evaluation cost $300 and Blue Guardian's cheapest standard $100K evaluation cost $239. Both firms run discounts, so check the price at checkout.

Which has better ratings, The 5%ers or Blue Guardian?

The 5%ers has a published rating of 4.7 and Blue Guardian 4.2, according to a Prop Firm Match snapshot. Ratings are one signal; read recent reviews and payout reports too.

Can I use the same platform at The 5%ers and Blue Guardian?

Yes. Both list MT5. Platform availability can vary by program, so check the specific challenge.

Is The 5%ers or Blue Guardian better for beginners?

Neither is automatically better. Beginners usually do best with a static drawdown, no time limit and a modest account size. Compare those rules on each firm's current program page and read our challenge types guide.

Ratings and review counts: Prop Firm Match snapshot. Fees: cheapest standard (non-promotional) price found on the date shown. Other fields: The Prop Navigator directory dataset. Not financial advice.

Affiliate partnerVSCapital
VSCapital — Trading through expertise. Start now.

We may earn a commission when you sign up through this partner link.